Here is an uncomfortable fact about experience: it doesn’t automatically make your judgment better. It makes you more confident. Whether it makes you more accurate depends on whether you can see, clearly and honestly, what you were thinking when you made your past decisions.
Most of us can’t. Memory rewrites the reasoning to fit the outcome. A call that worked out becomes, in hindsight, obviously right. A call that failed becomes a case of bad luck, or of someone else’s mistake. Either way, the lesson is lost.
The fix is unglamorous. Write the decision down before you know how it turns out.
This piece gives you the exact one-page format I recommend, how to fill it in quickly, and how to review it so it actually changes how you decide.
Why outcomes are a poor teacher
A good decision can produce a bad result, and a bad decision can get lucky. If you judge your past calls only by how they turned out, you’ll reward recklessness that happened to work and punish careful thinking that met bad luck.
The poker player and author Annie Duke calls this mistake “resulting”: judging the quality of a decision by the quality of its outcome.
What you want to judge is the quality of the reasoning given what you knew at the time. You can only do that if you captured what you knew at the time. Hence the record.
The format
Keep it to one page. If it takes longer than fifteen minutes to fill in, it won’t survive past the second week. Use these seven headings, in this order.
The decision
One sentence. Not the topic, the actual choice. “Hire a part-time operations assistant at 20 hours a week,” not “operations help.”
Type
Reversible or locked, using Tuesday’s test. This tells you how much of the rest to fill in. A reversible call might only need the decision, the options and your expectations.
What I know, and what I’m assuming
Two short lists. Facts you’d stake money on, and things you’re treating as true but haven’t checked. The second list is where most decisions go wrong, so be honest about it.
Options I considered
At least three, including “do nothing” and one you’d normally dismiss. If you only had one option, you didn’t make a decision. You made an announcement.
Why this one
The two or three reasons that actually tipped it. Not every reason, just the ones that carried weight.
What I expect to happen, and by when
Concrete and checkable. “Within eight weeks, I’ll have five more hours a week for client work.” Add how confident you are, as a rough percentage. You’ll be surprised how revealing that number becomes over time.
What would tell me I was wrong
The signal you’ll watch for. Write it now, while you’re calm, so you can’t quietly move the goalposts later.
Filling it in fast
You don’t need to be eloquent. Bullet points are fine. The aim is not a document anyone else reads. It’s an honest snapshot of your own head on the day.
Three habits make it easier.
Write it at the moment of commitment, not before. Once you’ve decided but before you’ve told anyone, take the fifteen minutes. That’s when your reasoning is freshest and least edited.
Keep them all in one place. A single document or folder, newest first. Scattered records are records you’ll never look at again.
Date everything. The date is what lets you compare your expectations with what actually happened.
The review: where the value is
A record you never revisit is just a diary. The learning happens in the review.
Put a reminder in your calendar for the date you set under “What I expect.” When it arrives, open the record and answer three questions in a line or two each.
What actually happened, compared with what I expected?
Which of my assumptions turned out to be wrong?
If I faced the same decision tomorrow, with only what I knew then, would I decide the same way?
That last question is the important one. It separates the quality of the decision from the luck of the outcome. If the answer is yes, a bad result doesn’t mean you need to change your approach. If the answer is no, a good result doesn’t mean you got it right.
What to look for over time
After ten or fifteen records, patterns appear. They are usually more useful than any single lesson.
You might find your confidence numbers are consistently too high, which tells you to slow down on locked decisions. You might find the same assumption failing again and again, perhaps about how fast other people move, or how long things take. You might find you rarely consider the “do nothing” option, and that when you do, it’s often the best one.
None of this is visible from memory. All of it is visible on paper.
Your assignment
Take the decision you classified after Tuesday’s piece. Before the week ends, fill in a record for it, all seven headings, fifteen minutes, no more. Set the review reminder.
If you’d like a second pair of eyes, reply to this email with your record, or just the decision and your list of assumptions. I read every one, and with your permission I may use an instructive one, anonymized, in a future piece.
— Nolan


